Home Cinema Choice logo

The future of hi-def? We get hands-on with Panasonic's first Freesat HD Blu-ray recorders

Steve May's picture

Panasonic will introduce a trio of high-specification Freesat HD digital recorders to the UK on June 20. The £999 DMR-BS850 and £899 DMR-BS750 are both Blu-ray recorders, sporting 500GB and 250GB hard drives respectively. They’ll be joined by the DMR-XS350, a DVD recorder with Freesat HD and a 250GB hard drive. While hi-def broadcasts can be recorded to the hard drive, the DVD recorder in the XS350 will only archive in SD.

At an exclusive preview, I got some hands-on time with these new Blu-ray models and came away hugely impressed. They are, without doubt, the most sophisticated digital TV recorders to ever hit the UK.

Maximum-def
Unlike Panasonic’s regular DVD recorders, all three models have twin Freesat HD tuners, meaning two channels can be recorded simultaneously. The decks also record the digital transport stream, allowing you to record on the HDD exactly what was broadcast, including full subtitles and audio descriptions. In this so-called DR mode, 77 hours of hi-def can be recorded on a 500GB drive.

But to increase the capacity of the hard drive and blank BD media, as well as comply with the Blu-ray video format, the machines will compress DR recordings with an in-built H.264 encoder.

Four recording modes are available (HG, HX, HE, HL) which reduce the bit-rate incrementally.

Eager to see the effect of this compression, I compared a DR original recording with an HL dub (effectively dropping from a bitrate of 14Mbps to just 4Mbps). The result was surprisingly good. While minimal compression artifacts were visible in the image, the picture was still undeniably hi-def. Using this HL mode, it’s possible to get 24 hours of HD video onto a 50GB BD-R. High-speed dubbing is also pretty nippy. A one hour show recorded in HL format can be copied to disc in just 1.5 minutes.

Both Blu-ray recorders sport Ethernet connections and are Profile 2.0 compliant. They also can tap into Panasonic’s nascent Viera Cast internet network, allowing video clips from YouTube to be played (full-screen) and searched. Users can also browse Picassa photo albums and, come the summer launch, have access to Bloomberg news and clips.

Global BD leader
Takuya Sugita director of Panasonic’s video equipment group (pictured right), told me that the company aims to be the global leader in Blu-ray technology. ‘The introduction of Blu-ray recorders into the Japanese market has been a huge success. Format penetration jumped from 1 per cent to 60 per cent in just 15 months. And Panasonic now has 45 per cent of the market.’

While no one expects these high-priced models to replace DVD recorders quite so quickly, expectations remain high.

The BD playback potential of the flagship player is best compared to the brand’s BD60 standalone player. Both Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD MA bitstream output is supported, and video processing is via the latest iteration of Panasonic’s UniPhier chipset.

According to marketing manager David Preece (pictured right), the new models are more than mere disc spinners, they’re home entertainment hubs: ‘The hard drive can be used as an audio jukebox. The recorders have an inbuilt Gracenote database of 350,000 albums. This can be updated via the recorder’s net connection when required.’

An SD card slot also allows playback of hi-res digital images and AVCHD files; there’s even a USB input for media playback.

One of the more surprising aspects of the Freesat HD implementation is a customized EPG, which makes recording easier than we’ve seen on the rival Humax Freesat HD PVR. When recording shows on ITV, which uses an awkward opt-in Red Button HD system, the EPG will automatically prompt you to record hi-def if an ITV show is being transmitted in the format; ditto simulcasts on BBC One and BBC HD. This is very useful for ITV, as you never really know when the commercial station will broadcast something in hi-def.

Copy Free or Copy Never?
Of course, there’s no guarantee that you’ll be able to record every HD show you fancy, or archive them to Blu-ray media. This is because broadcasters reserve the right to flag their transmissions as ‘Copy Free’, ‘Copy Once’ or ‘Copy Never.’

‘The BBC has informed us that once these recorders go on sale, they will move the majority of their broadcasts to Copy Free,’ promised Preece. ‘But if Hollywood, or a rights holder, specifically wants to restrict usage, a TV channel will broadcast ‘prohibit’ flags.’

Panasonic’s new Freesat HD recorders will make their public debut this weekend at The Gadget Show Live event, which runs at the NEC from 17-19th April. Look out for a full in-depth test of the new recorders in an upcoming issue of Home Cinema Choice.

Panasonic will also be embarking on a nationwide roadshow to show of the recorders and other new AV tech during June. Check it out when it comes to a town near you.

If you can't wait, you can also check out a review of the rival Humax Foxsat-HDR Freesat PVR here.

These decks look

These decks look fantastic.

Where on earth though are the twin tuner Freeview versions? It's so long overdue that Sony, Pioneer and Panasonic haven't released a twin tuner Freeview model and still give us a useless analogue tuner (for most people).

Also can these new Blu-ray models finally Pause and Rewind Live TV properly? Except for Philips all HDD/DVD Recorders do this in such an inefficient and woeful manner. Sky+ and Freeview+ boxes are significantly better at doing it. Which is why I have to own two boxes when I really only need one.

I forgot to add I'll pick up

I forgot to add I'll pick up one of these for sure, when they reach their 2nd-4th generation, meaning the price comes down to a reasonable rate.

Of course, what really holds

Of course, what really holds these decks back in the UK market is lack of content.

I doubt many are going to spend a grand just to record BBC HD and ITV HD, especially when Humax sell a Twin Tuner Freesat HD PVR for about £300-400.

I hope the Media Centre

I hope the Media Centre interface is decent, with album art support because this is what seriously lets down Pioneers equivalent on their HDD/DVD Recorders!

It's nowhere near as good as the likes of Windows Media Center.

Have homecinemachoice actually used a Humax HDR?

In the above article you state:-

One of the more surprising aspects of the Freesat HD implementation is a customized EPG, which makes recording easier than we’ve seen on the rival Humax Freesat HD PVR. When recording shows on ITV, which uses an awkward opt-in Red Button HD system, the EPG will automatically prompt you to record hi-def if an ITV show is being transmitted in the format; ditto simulcasts on BBC One and BBC HD. This is very useful for ITV, as you never really know when the commercial station will broadcast something in hi-def.

Which is exactly what the Humax HDR does. Maybe it's worth actually using both products in future to give an accurate review to readers.

Yes we have!

Rik Henderson's picture

We have reviewed the Humax Foxsat-HDR in the print edition of Home Cinema Choice (published back in January).

I've now posted the pdf of that review in the Reviews Archive here. Check it out.

Rik Henderson
Deputy Editor
Home Cinema Choice

Thanks Rik. I'll take a

Thanks Rik. I'll take a look. I'll probably hold out for Freeview HD (especially as I live in a rented flat) but it does look nice.

Why is the PDF a whopping 24Mb? It's really slow to navigate.

The incredible shrinking pdf

Rik Henderson's picture

Oh yeah, sorry about that. The downloadable pdf is now a much more manageable 200Kb.

Rik Henderson
Deputy Editor
Home Cinema Choice

re: Humax HDR review

Rik,

Ok, so having opinions is what a review is all about, but seriously, you need to ask how would someone intend to use the product. Would you:

a) Be looking for something in hi-def to record / watch.

b) Find a programme that you are interested in, and record / watch it in hi-def if available?

Most people, most of the time would be doing (b). And the Humax handles that situation quite well - even with ITV HD. You find a programme, go to record it, and if there is a HD stream you get the option to record that instead.

Even watching live, the red button indicator is a clear means of notification (more so than BBC!)

That's not to say the service isn't flawed. There are some issues with the Humax interface (the forced creation of folders that take extra steps to delete, unable to delete whilst a recording is in progress).

And of course, it's reliant on the quality of the EPG data - something that ITV has always struggled with (a few times they've either not put HD info into the EPG when there is a HD stream, or had the HD info when there isn't).

But the comment about trawling through the EPG looking for HD programmes seems a bit silly - given how people are likely to use it.

Copy

Drawback on this product is that there is no hi def input. Means you cannot copty from cable TV

  • In the latest Home Cinema Choice:
    We review Denon's mighty universal Blu-ray deck, the £4,500 DVD-A1UD – truly the Bugatti Veyron of disc spinners. Plus, LG's first seamless LED TV is on test. And we give you a world exclusive peek at what's coming after 3D TV, Sony's 360-degree Photonic Viewer...
    Love home cinema? Then get HCC #178, out now!